SAARC is Dead. Now What? The Future of South Asian Cooperation .
Does SAARC fail because of Asians or system is behind it.
Published 2 months ago
We live next door to each other, but we act like strangers.
India, Pakistan, Bangladesh, Sri Lanka, Nepal, Bhutan, Maldives, Afghanistan.
8 countries. 2 billion people. One shared region.
And one regional organization that hasn’t held a summit since 2014.
SAARC — the South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation — was supposed to be our version of the EU. Free trade, student exchanges, joint disaster response, easier visas.
Instead it became a group chat with no admin. Everyone’s in it, no one’s talking.
So if SAARC is dead, what happens next? Do we just give up on working together, or is there another way forward for South Asia?
What Went Wrong ?
SAARC didn’t collapse in one day. It was death by a thousand cuts.
1. India-Pakistan tensions :
Every time there’s a border flare-up, summits get cancelled. The last one was supposed to be in Islamabad in 2016. It never happened. When the two biggest economies in the region can’t sit in the same room, nothing moves.
2. Politics over people :
SAARC’s charter bans discussing bilateral disputes. Sounds good on paper. In reality, it meant SAARC could never talk about the actual things blocking cooperation: Kashmir, terrorism, water. So leaders just stopped showing up.
3. Bilateral > Regional :
Countries found it easier to do deals one-on-one. India signs trade deals with UAE. Pakistan goes deep with China through CPEC . Bangladesh trades more with China than with Pakistan. Why wait for 8 countries to agree when you can call 1?
4. COVID was the final nail :
The pandemic could’ve been SAARC’s moment. Instead, countries coordinated through WHO and bilaterally. The habit of meeting died.
What’s Happening Instead :
SAARC may be on life support, but South Asia didn’t stop cooperating. It just got smaller and messier.
BIMSTEC: 7 countries including India, Bangladesh, and Sri Lanka. No Pakistan. Focus on trade and connectivity.
BBIN: Bangladesh, Bhutan, India, Nepal. Working on road and energy links.
SCO : Shanghai Cooperation Organisation. Brings Pakistan, India, and China to one table, but it’s dominated by China and Russia.
Direct deals : CPEC for Pakistan. India’s “Neighbourhood First” policy. US-India tech partnerships.
Basically, we moved from “all 8 together” to “mini-clubs” and bilateral deals. Faster, but also more fragmented.
What South Asia Is Losing :
This isn’t just about diplomacy. It hits your wallet in Karachi.
Trade :Intra-SAARC trade is only about $23 billion. For comparison, intra-ASEAN trade is over $600 billion. We trade more with countries far away than with our neighbors. That means higher prices for onions from India, medicines from Bangladesh, and cement from Sri Lanka.
Climate: We share the same monsoon, same smog, same melting glaciers. But there’s no joint early warning system or river management beyond the Indus Treaty.
People : A student in Lahore can’t easily do a semester in Delhi. A businessman in Dhaka can’t get a SAARC business visa that actually works. We’re 2 billion people living in silos.
So What Comes Next? 3 Possible Futures :
*Option A: Revive SAARC, “SAARC Minus One”*
Hold summits without the country blocking consensus. It’s undiplomatic, but ASEAN did it. At least keep the dialogue alive on health, education, and disaster relief.
*Option B: Issue-Based Coalitions*
Forget the big summit. Create small groups just for water, or climate, or energy. The Indus Commission still meets even when everything else is frozen. More of that.
*Option C: Let Others Shape It*
If South Asians don’t cooperate, China will through BRI and SCO. The US will through the Quad and IPEF. We’d still be connected, but on someone else’s terms.
None of these are perfect. But doing nothing is the worst option.
*The Reason:
SAARC didn’t fail because South Asians don’t need each other. We share rivers, roads, food, and problems.
It failed because we let politics come before people.
The question isn’t “can South Asia cooperate?” The question is “what are we willing to cooperate on first?”
Maybe it starts small. A joint flood warning system. Easier medical visas. Students swapping universities.
Because the alternative is another 10 years of paying more, talking less, and letting other regions write the rules for
More from Writing
Deepfakes: A Double-Edged Sword in International Relations and Global Security:
Deepfakes have evolved from a digital nuisance into a real national security threat capable of fueling political and military crises. But could this same technology also help fight the misinformation it creates?
Read postFrom Cradle to Screens: Raising Tomorrow's Generation
Technology shapes childhood, but balance builds the future.
Read postThe New Oil: How Lithium and Rare Earths are Rewriting Global Power
For a century oil ruled the world, but now power has shifted to who controls lithium and rere Earth's processing.
Read post
Responses
Log in to comment and join the discussion.
Log in